Russian Prosecutors Urge Dismissal of Khachaturyan Sisters Murder Case, Citing Self-Defense After Eight-Year Probe

Russian state prosecutors told Moscow's Basmanny District Court on November 18 that Krestina, Angelina, and Maria Khachaturyan acted in "necessary self-defense" when they killed their abusive father in July 2018, demanding that the eight-year murder prosecution be terminated and all pre-trial restrictions lifted. The intervention—reported by state wire services RIA Novosti and TASS alongside independent outlets Meduza, Echo FM, and Russian domestic portal *Pravmir*—marks the sharpest institutional rift yet between Russia's supervisory prosecution service and the Investigative Committee over one of the country's most consequential domestic-violence cases. Yet because Russian criminal procedure restricts courts from directly overriding an investigator's pre-trial measures, the sisters remain barred from speaking to one another for now. ### Why Prosecutors and Investigators Are Deadlocked The procedural confrontation exposed in Basmanny District Court on November 18 centers on a rare public collision between two pillars of Russia's law-enforcement apparatus. Hearing a defense complaint filed on behalf of the youngest sister, Maria Khachaturyan—represented by attorney Yaroslav Pakulin—the prosecutor declared the case investigator's actions "unlawful" and accused investigators of causing "egregious delays" by repeatedly extending the inquiry without a final ruling. Speaking to *Pravmir*, defense lawyer Mari Davtyan, who represents Angelina Khachaturyan and has worked on domestic-violence cases for over a decade, revealed that the Prosecutor General's Office has actually been demanding the termination of the sisters' prosecution since **April 2026** on the grounds that no crime was committed (*otsutstviye sostava prestupleniya*). Despite that supervisory directive, the Investigative Committee investigator maintained in a formal written submission to the court that evidence still tied the sisters to their father's death and refused to lift preventive restrictions. That refusal was handed back by the bench. On November 17, Basmanny District Court upheld a defense delay complaint and took the unusual step of issuing a formal **private ruling (*chastnoye postanovleniye*)** addressed directly to the leadership of the investigative body over procrastination and failure to execute prosecutorial orders. On November 18, the court ruled the investigator's refusal to reconsider Maria's restrictions unlawful as well. ### Eight Years After 2018—and a 2025 Posthumous Verdict The deadlock looks even starker against the legal record established in 2025. Krestina, Angelina, and Maria—then aged 19, 18, and 17—were arrested in July 2018 after admitting they killed their 57-year-old father, Mikhail Khachaturyan, following years of documented physical, psychological, and sexual abuse. After initial detention, they were placed under strict preventive restrictions that still prohibit the three sisters from contacting each other, while Maria has remained barred from using a phone or the internet for more than eight years (contacts with their mother are permitted). In **April 2025**, following a posthumous trial consented to by Mikhail Khachaturyan's relatives, a Moscow court found the deceased father guilty of violent sexual acts against his daughters, causing serious bodily harm, and distributing pornography—a verdict Moscow City Court upheld on appeal in **November 2025**. Rather than closing the daughters' file afterward, however, the Investigative Committee reopened the murder inquiry in **January 2026** to examine whether the sisters had exceeded the legal limits of permissible self-defense. For Russian legal analysts and women's rights advocates, that sequence highlights a structural gap in Russian criminal law: Russia still lacks a dedicated domestic-violence statute, leaving victims who fight back during prolonged abuse exposed to prosecution under standard homicide rules unless investigators recognize imminent threat at the moment of the act. ### What Happens Next for the Three Sisters Despite two consecutive courtroom victories on November 17 and 18, defense lawyers caution against expecting immediate relief. As Mari Davtyan explained to *Pravmir*, Russian courts lack the statutory authority to directly annul an investigator's pre-trial measure during an active preliminary probe; the Basmanny court can only declare the refusal unlawful and compel the investigator to reconsider the defense motion promptly. Still, the dual pressure of a formal court rebuke to Investigative Committee leadership and an explicit on-the-record self-defense finding by state prosecutors sharply narrows the investigator's room to stall. Maria's attorney, Yaroslav Pakulin, told TASS (via Echo FM) that the court found no persuasive grounds for dragging the investigation out further, raising defense expectations that the criminal case could finally be closed on rehabilitative grounds—recognizing necessary self-defense—before the end of 2026. Whether the Investigative Committee yields within the coming month will test how much authority Russia's courts and prosecutors can still exert over protracted criminal probes. ### Sources & Further Reading - [Meduza — Russian Prosecutors Call for an End to the Khachaturyan Sisters' Murder Case, Saying They Acted in Self-Defense](https://meduza.io/en/news/2026/11/18/russian-prosecutors-call-for-an-end-to-the-khachaturyan-sisters-murder-case-saying-they-acted-in-self-defense-when-they-killed-their-abusive-father) - [The Moscow Times — Prosecution Seeks to Drop Khachaturyan Sisters Murder Case](https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2026/11/18/prosecution-seeks-to-drop-khachaturyan-sisters-murder-case-a94304) - [Pravmir (Russia) — Генпрокуратура признала действия сестер Хачатурян самообороной: интервью с Мари Давтян](https://www.pravmir.ru/genprokuratura-predlozhila-prekratit-delo-sester-hachaturyan-priznav-ih-dejstviya-samooboronoj/) - [Echo FM (Russia) — Адвокат Марии Хачатурян: генпрокуратура сочла необходимой самообороной действия сестёр](https://echofm.online/news/advokat-marii-hachaturyan-genprokuratura-sochla-neobhodimoj-samooboronoj-dejstviya-sestyor-hachaturyan) ~WorldNews ~Russia ~Justice ~HumanRights ~RuleOfLaw

Russian Prosecutors Urge Dismissal of Khachaturyan Sisters Murder Case, Citing Self-Defense After Eight-Year Probe
0
Discuss 0 0
0 replies
Be the first to join this thread.